Project

General

Profile

Support #11153

document the change in the production yield of kaons between Geant4 versions 9.6.p04 and 10.1.p02

Added by Krzysztof Genser almost 5 years ago. Updated almost 5 years ago.

Status:
Resolved
Priority:
Normal
Start date:
12/15/2015
Due date:
01/30/2016
% Done:

100%

Estimated time:
Experiment:
DUNE
Duration: 47

Description

Explain and document the change in the production yield of kaons
(electron neutrinos) between versions 9.6.p04 and 10.1.p02 when
120 GeV protons strike thin Carbon target

History

#1 Updated by Hans-Joachim Wenzel almost 5 years ago

The changes as reported by Paul Lebrun are well understood and documented by the geant 4 collaboration (see e.g. release notes for geant 4 release 4.10.1
https://geant4.web.cern.ch/geant4/support/ReleaseNotes4.10.1.html or see validation results concerning k/pi ratio from validation test 19: High energy test, provides comparison with NA61 (31 GeV/c proton beam) and NA49 (158 GeV/c proton beam) data sets which can be found in the geant 4 validation databases). We also contacted he experts to discuss our observation.
There have been number of changes in geant 4 QGS model. The changes started out as early as Geant4.10.0 series, and propagated into geant4.10.1 cycle, including geant4.10.1.p02. Motivation for the change was to make the geant 4 implementation to closer resemble the original theoretical paper. The changes while yet incomplete resulted in a better agreement of kaon/pion production ratio between simulation and experiment. This is documented in the attached figures which have been extracted from the Geant 4 validation repository:
http://g4validation.fnal.gov:8080/G4WebAppNG/
We have kept Paul Lebrun in loop and communicated our findings.
The experimental data which was used to make the plots is at lower proton incident energies than what is used at the numi beam line. We are evaluating if data from the fermilab mipp experiment can be used for future validation (same proton energy).


Also available in: Atom PDF